At this time last year, I surpassed 30,000 lifetime miles on my 2013 BMC Granfondo GF02, which is still great today after even more time and more miles. However, it is an aging 2x10-speed aluminum bike with rim brakes. That’s not where the industry is today, much less where it will be tomorrow. When things break or wear out, finding replacement parts will only get more challenging and more expensive.
I’m close to 6,000 lifetime miles aboard my 2022 Framed Gravier, a capable bike for a ride on the Eisenbahn State Trail, but not something I would want to ride on the road any more than necessary. It’s heavy and the gearing is all wrong for me. On one hand, I like the simplicity of the single chainring. On the other, I’m usually riding at 40x11 and wishing I had more gears.
You already should have guessed where this is going.
All year long, I was thinking about a new bike that could replace both the BMC and the Framed, simplifying things for me in my most common riding scenarios. After much deliberation, last week I decided the 2025 Scott Addict is the solution.
Scott makes different versions of the Addict. For me, the right choice was the Shimano 105 12-speed mechanical version. I think it’s a better value with less hassle than the Shimano 105 Di2 version; the bikes are identical otherwise. I’m not a fetishist when it comes to bike technology. Electronic shifting is cool, but it comes with its own set of worries and a much higher price tag. Today’s 105 group performs as well as yesterday’s top-of-the-line DURA-ACE group with only a small weight penalty. I’m getting more climbing gears (11-34) than I have with the BMC (11-28), more top-end gearing (50-tooth big ring) than I have with the Framed, and hydraulic disc brakes, an improvement over both the BMC and the Framed. And like all modern road bikes, the Scott has clearance for wider tires. Its stock 32mm tires will be fine on the road and on a gentle gravel trail like the Eisenbahn, where I have been using similar 32mm tires on the Framed for the last three years. The Scott’s stock wheels are surprisingly good and contribute to a noticeably smoother ride. They are only slightly heavier than the wheels on the BMC and they are almost a full pound lighter than the wheels that came with the Framed! They’re even lighter than the custom wheels I ordered to replace the Framed’s stock set.
While Scott began as an American company, it is now headquartered in Switzerland, and its product offerings are known better to the European market. In the US, you can find versions of the Giant Defy and the Trek Domane that are almost identical to my new Addict – carbon frames, Shimano 105 12-speed mechanical drivetrains, unspectacular yet eminently serviceable house brand wheels, saddles, handlebars, etc. – but they don’t come close to the Addict on price. And price is always a consideration. As I was reviewing my options, total cost of ownership was a thought. So was timing. I think we are heading into a period of significantly higher prices driven by new tariffs. Anything coming from overseas – and that’s almost everything in the bike industry – is going to cost more. I didn’t want to wait any longer. You can still find deals on stuff that is already in the US. A lot of companies in a lot of different industries front-loaded their shipments this year to get ahead of the tariffs. But once that stuff is gone, the next wave of stuff will be more expensive.
I don’t plan to part with the BMC. If it is to become only a backup road bike, then it will be a great backup road bike. The Framed, though, is looking for a new purpose. I already have stripped it of its pedals, bottle cages, computer mount, and saddle. (The stock saddle on the Addict was too short for my riding style, and it’s 30 grams heavier.) As a single chainring bike with mechanical disc brakes and plenty of tire clearance, a pair of flat pedals could turn the Framed into an all-season, urban errand runner. Or this could simply be time to find a new owner for it.
On today’s 35-mile shakedown ride, the Addict performed flawlessly. The only thing that would have made it better was a heater. What’s up with our weather? Is this August or October? It would be typical of my luck for me to have purchased a great bike right before the early arrival of a chilly autumn. Give me at least a few more nice weeks, please!